|
Kaka : Why the Man City Project is
doomed to failure
By
Editor • Nov 30th, 2008 • Category: Articles
AC
Milan chief Adriano Galliani is no stranger to football corruption,
but then again that is not uncommon in the crazy world of Italian
football where match fixing - or at least allegations of it - have
been a stain on the history of the modern Serie A. An
administrator, entrepreneur, executive call him whatever you want,
the distinctive looking Italian is one of the main associates and
spokesmen of the Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi.
Always smiling or politically stern when required, immaculately
dressed and statesman like Galliani was most recently heavily
implicated in the now infamous 'Calciogate' or CalcioPoli
investigations. Far from impeached or jailed though Galliani was
banned from Italian football for a some five months but just like
Berlusconi he finds himself again back involved at the top of the
game despite previous and quite serious misdemeanor's.

Outwith
the accusations of football sleaze and corruption the professional
track record of Galliani is impressive. He is most famously known as
being both the one time Chief Executive Officer of AC Milan as well
as having a spell as President of Serie A. His time at the club has
again co-incided with AC Milan achieving at the pinnacle of the game
with Champions League success and club associations with noted brands
such as Adidas and fashion brand Dolce & Gabbana. Today in 2008
Galliani is currently the highest ranked administrator of A.C. Milan
after Berlusconi stepped down from being chairman since becoming the
PM for a third, yet possibly not last time.
Galliani
was apparently the main figurehead behind the signing of David
Beckham and he made a telling point when David Beckham signed from LA
Galaxy on loan during the MLS break. With the flash bulb
media conference over and Beckham posing in photographs for the
world's press with black and red striped shirt in hands, the
figurehead spoke of how the Milan club were not a just a club but a
'Media Company' as well. With film star footballers such
as Beckham, Maldini and Kaka at the club Milan have been at the
pinnacle of the game both in terms of success and finance for many
years but the same cannot be said for Manchester City.
Just
like Manchester United the AC Milan 'brand' has grown over the years
in tandem to Champions League success but the tale of success goes
even further back than that. In short AC Milan has rightfully earned
its place as a media company. Whilst the sky blue of
Manchester City has always been on the shoogly peg of uncertainty the
famous black and red striped shirts have long had a hanger in the
wordrobe of football success. Both Deloitte and Forbes
Wealth have assessed Milan and they are rated, aparently, as one of
the richest clubs in the world in terms of revenue. But forget
Manchester United's three Champions League wins and Liverpool's five
as Milan have won the trophy seven times across a variety of eras
including the 1960's, the 1980's, 1990's and the most recently in
2007. Put that together with being runners up four times and winning
the Cup Winners Cup twice and you can see that with Milan, success
has been a way of life. Milan has righfully earned its place
as a media company.

Milan's
history has not always been a story of success. Implication in the
Totonero betting scandel saw Milan relegated to Serie B in 1980 and a
period of underachievment and decline set in. Milan went from from a
club of greats such as Gianni Rivera to one of mediocrity and names
like Joe Jordon, Luther Blissitt and Mark Hateley. But inside
those teams was the backbone of the modern era with players such as
Franco Baresi. It was players such as Baresi and the incoming of
Silvio Berlusconi, Arrigo Sacchi and and the improvement of the San
Siro that the club reached its former heights once again. Names such
as Van Basten, Gullit, Ancellotti and Rossi went on to carve an era
of success for Milan only matched by fellow giants Ajax and Juventus.
Today
one look at the AC Milan website sees names such as Dolce and
Gabbana, Opel and Adidas adorn the club advertising and web
communication tools. The website can be read in Portugeuse, Japanese,
Chinese, Italian and English hinting both at the multi-national
identity of the clubs players and the global outreach of the brand.
The once famous Mediolanum sponsor has passed through Opel, Meriva
and Zafira to the current sponsor Bwin. And the deal is not a gamble
as whilst Manchester United's deal with AIG was always on the rocky
road to ruin, Milan's deal is secure for 4 years. Similarly the deal
with Adidas is equally lucrative until at least 2018. Off the field
many of Milan's players are the faces of some of the fashion
industry's most famous labels. Andrei Shevchenko went from the
anonimity of a humble Ukraine upbringing to be was chosen as the face
of Giorgio Armani and marrying American model Kristen Pazik along the
way.
Kaka
joined Milan in 2003 and has since gone onto become a Italian
citizen; a sort of mild joint nationality. Early life injury and
subsequent recovery saw a declaration of devout religiousness but
this has not stopped Kaka becoming one of the richest players in the
world with a reported salary of around 200,000 euros a week. Every
goal Kaka scores meanwhile is greeted with a finger to the heavens
and god sees some of his money as well, with Kaka sending some of his
weekly wage packet to his local church in Sao Paulo. Alongside
Zidane, Totti, Torres, Raul, Ronaldo and Beckham, Kaka is one of the
world's superstar footballers and with Beckham now at Milan, all be
it temporary, he is now on first name terms with Beckham. Posh
Spice's other half meanwhile calls Kaka 'Ricky' a name by which he
appears to be known amongst his colleagues with Kaka if you like
being his 'stage' name.
So
where then, I hear you ask, do Manchester City come into this? Well
things have gone crazy in Manchester since new ownership became the
fashion in the circus of the English Premiership and the blue half of
Manchester went first Thai and now Arabian. Far from BYOB the Thai
brought with him a barrow load of cash and new players by the dozen.
The Thai Prime Minister 'Frank Sinatra' Thaksin Shinawatra brought
hope and excitement to the blue half. Former England coach Sven Goran
Erikkson was brought in to lead the club playing wise and a plethora
of foreign talent came as well. The trouble was too many of those who
came in were little more than average at least by Premiership
standards. Exceptions to the rule were Elano and Martin Petrov who
proved to be quality players performing at a consistant high level.
Success still eluded Manchester City however and constant speculation
surrounding the affairs of the Thai PM led to his departure.
Just
prior to the commencement of the 2008-2009 season Manchester City
went Arabian in its taste. Essentially the club went up
market and moved from Thai cuisine to four wives and a piano and new
Abu Dhabi based owners. Far from Jonathon Ross though a PR disaster
of epic proportions did not set in immediately and instead Manchester
City themselves became the talk of the north. The timing of the
takeover sparked various "deadline-day" rumours and hurried
transfer bids such as an attempt to out-do Man Utd's protracted bid
to sign Berbatov. Surprisingly as well despite it being a close
shave, Brazilian Robinho was signed from Real Madrid for around £30
million under the noses of Chelsea. It was all very fake though with
Manchester City hovering around mid-table and cup exits being the
norm. The only exception was the UEFA cup where qualification was
achieved for the last 32 of the trophy. As 2009 approached suddenly
the name of Kaka cropped up and it was reported a bid of over £100
million had been made. For a while the deal looked as if it might
happen or so at least the publicity surrounding the deal said but it
eventually died despite an offer of a 500,000 euros a week salary
being made to Kaka.
Former
Nike executive Garry Cook came on board at Manchester City in May
2008 with his appointment as executive chairman of the club in May
2008, and there in lies one of the key problems. Not soon after his
arrival, Manchester City went from being a average distinguised
traditional football club to a 'project' and a 'journey' as Cook
called it. Just as Hughes job was to produce a
winning team so Cook's job was to get Manchester City to the pinnacle
of the global game but if you look at it there in questions of Cook
start being raised already already. If such an ambition
was held why did Manchester City move from a world famous coach with
a global track record in Sven Goran Erikkson to one as respectable
yet clearly average as Mark Hughes?
Unlike
AC Milan, Manchester City have never had a track record of success
through whatever era. The blue half of Manchester will always be
famous for players such as Summerbee, Franny Lee and Denis Law but
even they made there names elsewhere. Last winners of the
Old First division as 1967 the club were in the old second division
as recently as 2002 and the only semblance of European success came
in 1970 with victory over Gornik Zabre in the now defunct ECWC.
Meanwhile, players such as Kaka, Shevchenko and Maldini have found a
natural habitat at clubs like Milan just as fellow greats like Van
Baston, Gullit and Rikjaard before them. Robinho may be at Manchester
City Football Club today but the Football Club part of the club title
would be as well being replaced with 'for the moment' such are the
facts of life. Lets face it, players like
Robinho did not come to Manchester City for the football. Whilst Kaka
has found his natural habitat at Milan, Robinho is like a 'fish out
of water' at the City of Manchester Stadium. The Premiership is a
jungle of opportunity but for the time being Manchester City are
swinging from a loose rope.
The
fact of the matter is that people like Gary Cook have went from
executive sales with Nike to finding natural habitat at Premiership
football clubs. Such a thing would have been unheard of whilst Man
City played at Maine Road but today its the norm. Just like the
people who lead our financial sector and banks on the rocky road to
ruin and disaster so Manchester City find themselves in a no-mans
land of underachievment and over inflated amibitions.
Cook is full of the empty vocabulary of modern football marketing
jargon but it is all very ill-fitting at a club as small and a
insignificant as Manchester City. At Milan such a rhetoric fits
fashionably alongside brands such as Dolce & Gabbana, Maldini and
Opel but this fails to be the case alongside Le Coq Sportif, Thomas
Cook and Micah Richards.
The
project that Gary Cook speaks so enthusiastically about is one that
is doomed to failure and has been long before the Kaka soap opera
started. Basically it is impossible to build a fooball team from the
top downwards, but it is especially difficult when it is a club which
has failure ingrained on its history as much as Manchester City.
Whether
Kaka was ever realistically ever going to sign for Manchester City we
shall never know. If you are truly cynical then you could say that
the whole episode was a Public relations stunt played out by a media
company called AC Milan and its budding franchise Manchester City.
Failing that maybe Cook had hoped to sign Kaka but thankfully he saw
sense avoided the journet and stayed put to play for a real world
class club rather than a 'project'. The fact is for clubs like
AC Milan success and lofty status is a matter of fact rather than
delusional ambition as it is and always will be for for Manchester
City. If you want to use jargon to sum the whole charade up its this;
Manchester City is a journey rather than a football club and the road
to hell rather than success is ahead.
|